Edward Murphy was an aerospace engineer who is responsible for Murphy's Law: If anything bad can happen it will!
Last month I appeared before the S.F. Bay Area Options Group with a rare stock/DITM recommendation that I thought highly profitable as well as a margin of safety - Cliff Resources, which I personally bought at $70/share. At the time of the talk, it was $67 - today it is $47.
Condolences on anyone who followed me into this torpedo - but I still feel this 1 of a 100 instance is more a reason FOR DITM, than against it.
Being a Technician, I usually rely on other "experts" for Fundamental Analysis - S&P, Schwab, Ned Davis, Reuters, etc. S&P still rates CLF 4*, Merrill just lowered it to Neutral after it fell over 50% from its 2011 high!! It now seems that the excessive Premium in the Call was,as usual, warranted for things to come (expected IV). In my talk I mentioned that, as I was going on vacation, I would put on a Bear put spread below my Call price (62 1/2) - I did: 57 1/2 X 55 puts. I paid $.30 and closed them for a $2.43 profit; I have since traded 50 X 47 1/2 spreads and now in a weekly 50 X 49 - all profitable and ITM.
Just as with BP in 2010 - it was a Perfect Storm - May has seen huge declines in stocks (worst month for down days for awhile) with which CLF is highly correlated; commodities - Oil down 18%, Gold down 6% MTD are also tanking; with RS Steel going bankrupt , all steels are dropping with China's slowdown. It appears to be a Blood-In-The-Street moment.
Technicians know that historically, the first trading day of the month (e.g.,tomorrow) outperforms the rest of the month combined. On Oct.4, 2011, CLF spiked down to $47.31 - today's low (so far) $47.06. Hopefully, Buyers will again come in at this level. My SELL filter is to break support with 3 daily closes - I hope to hold on throughout tomorrow's Unemployment release.
TALE OF TWO TRADES:
Had I only bought 200 CLF, my loss would now be $4600 (less $125) in dividends.
If CLF stays the same (unlikely) until Oct., or I bail out - my overall loss would be under $1500 - still bad. If it rebounds, as most stocks to with a V-spike: original profits, plus $270 from the Put spreads, would be gained by Oct. expiry.
We shall know in the fullness of time!
Until the market can show me that it is in an uptrend I don't think buying and hold or DITM calls is a good strategy. Shorting stock, put spreads and selling DITM calls may provide better results.
ReplyDelete